Exergy Balance of Material Recycling and Energy Generation of Waste Materials: Case Studies
The Saubermacher Dienstleistungs AG is active in the field of waste management and is inter-ested in an energy and exergy balance of the material recycling and energy generation of differ-ent waste materials, to find out, what is the most appropriate waste management option.
The aim is to find out the frame work conditions under which the material recycling or the energy gener-ation makes more sense and if the exergy balance gives different results compared to the energy balance. For the following four case studies - aluminum, waste plastic, waste paper and house-hold waste - the comparison was made based on life cycle assessment (LCA) and the main in-fluencing factors were analyzed. The exergy and energy balances were analyzed based on a life cycle assessment, which is a method to estimate the environmental impacts of a product in its entire life cycle - "from cradle to grave". Starting with the type and amount of energy (e.g. heat, electricity) and auxiliary materials used the amount of primary energy was calculated, which are necessary for the waste treatment options. All the different primary energy carriers including the heating value of the waste are included in the energy and exergy balance of the material recy-cling and energy generation of the considered waste materials in the four case studies.
The following results were obtained for the case studies:
- The comparison of the material recycling and energy generation of waste materials can only be done based on a life cycle perspective.
- The comparison must be based on the same amount of waste material (e.g. 1 t) and the same amount of services provided by the waste management option (e.g. x MWh electricity, y MWh heat, z t product) which means that within the system boundaries of the material re-cycling an energy system and in the system boundaries of the energy generation a product system must be added.
- The cumulated primary energy demand calculated on a life cycle bases of the different waste management option can be used to assess the energy and exergy efficiencies.
- In general the assessment of the exergy efficiency leads to the same results compared to the energy efficiency in the comparison of the different waste management options.
- Aluminum: the recycling of aluminum has significantly higher energy efficiency than the production of virgin aluminum.
- Household waste: The energy and exergy efficiencies of the energy generation from house-hold waste are similar in the cement industry and in waste incineration plants. The efficien-cy in cement industry is significantly higher, if only electricity and no district heat is pro-duced in the waste incineration plant. In contrast a high utilization rate of the heat from the waste incineration plant gives a higher efficiency compared to the use of household waste in the cement industry. The results strongly depend on the electric and thermal efficiency of the waste incineration plant.
- Waste plastics: The energy and exergy efficiencies of the energy generation from waste plastic are only slightly higher compared to the material recycling. If most of the waste plas-tic can be recycled to new products and the energy demand of recycling is low, than the en-ergy and exergy efficiency of material recycling of waste plastic might be higher compared to the energy generation.
- Waste paper: The energy and exergy efficiencies of the energy generation of waste paper is only significantly higher, if the unused wood in case of material recycling is not used for energy and remains in the forest for natural oxidation.
ASK - Unser Kooperationspartner
Unsere 3 aktuellsten Fachartikel
Folgen und Perspektiven für eine klimaschonende Nutzung kohlenstoffreicher Böden in der Küstenregion Niedersachsens
© Springer Vieweg | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH (10/2025)
Der Schutz von Mooren und somit kohlenstoffreicher Böden ist ein zentrales Element erfolgreicher Klimaschutzstrategien. Am Beispiel der Küstenregion Niedersachsens wird deutlich, welche sozioökonomischen Folgen eine Wiedervernässung ohne wirtschaftliche Nutzungsperspektiven nach sich ziehen kann. Eine transformative Moornutzung kann nur gelingen, wenn wissenschaftliche Erkenntnisse, politische Rahmenbedingungen, soziale Akzeptanz und ökonomische Realitäten ineinandergreifen.
Zur Berücksichtigung globaler Klimafolgen bei der Zulassung von Abfallentsorgungsanlagen
© Lexxion Verlagsgesellschaft mbH (9/2025)
Der Text untersucht, wie Klimafolgenprüfungen bei Deponien und Abfallanlagen rechtlich einzuordnen sind. Während das UVPG großräumige Klimaauswirkungen fordert, lehnt das BVerwG deren Prüfung im Immissionsschutzrecht ab. Daraus ergeben sich offene Fragen zur Zulassung und planerischen Abwägung von Deponien.
In-situ-Erhebung der Schädigung von Fischen beim Durchgang großer Kaplan-Turbinen
© Springer Vieweg | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH (9/2025)
Schädigungen der heimischen Fischarten Aitel, Nase und Äsche bei der Turbinenpassage wurde mittels HI-Z-Tags an zwei mittelgroßen Laufkraftwerken untersucht. Bei juvenilen Fischen wurden Überlebensraten (48 h) zwischen 87 % und 94 % gefunden, bei den adulten Fischen zwischen 75 % und 90 %. Die geringeren Schädigungen am Murkraftwerk im Vergleich zum Draukraftwerk können plausibel durch eine geringere Zahl an Turbinenflügeln (vier statt fünf), eine geringere Fallhöhe und eine etwas langsamer laufende Turbine erklärt werden.
